AI Dungeon in 2026 – The Yearning Shall Continue [Review]

If there is one gaming-related thing in 2026 that impresses me, it’s the current version of AI Dungeon. I remember trying it out in 2019 or so when it was released, and it wasn’t too enticing. A novelty for sure, getting semi-coherent messages back that could be interpreted as an adventure—but it was rough, that’s the least I can say. However, trying it now in 2026, it’s a totally different beast!

The Malfoid
The thing that prompted me to try it again, so many years later, was the Malfoid meme—the idea of changing Draco Malfoy from Harry Potter to a beautiful, “tsundere” type of woman with an acid disdain that only a pure-blood aristocrat could produce. Yet, of course, with a heart of gold, if you get to know her. And like many others, I was smitten with the concept and I’m not even a big Harry Potter fan! It fixes so many things in the movies, and it’s extremely romantic compared to whatever Ginny was supposed to be (Harry’s girlfriend). [Here is an excellent video on the subject by YouTuber Professor Ransom].

To a long and fruitful friendship, hopefully

So, I, like many others (mostly men) got captivated by it, and I wanted to experience the classic romance for myself, and here is where AI Dungeon enters the picture. Someone over in the community tab had already made an excellent scenario for this exact story, called Slytherin to your Heart—where you play as an 8th year transfer to Hogwarts. It’s a somewhat raunchy but mostly wholesome experience, and don’t worry—everyone is 18 or 19 years old taking on the 8th year of magical school.

Does it work?
Yes, and the mechanics at a basic level are the same as from 2019, but vastly improved—and when it really works it feels like you are writing a grand adventure together with the computer constructing it as a game. You pick a scenario or create one, and then you just input what you say, do, or what happens in the story, and then the AI provides (often) very realistic and coherent scenarios that follow a narrative line. Compared to the 2019 version, it is night and day. Back then, the AI forgot things that happened after three turns, making every turn a battle against a perpetual goldfish of doom. It kills all immersion having the story drop that important pledge of protecting the city from demons after five minutes. What demons, what rewards? Guards, arrest this scammer!

This leads me to memory: how much is fixed, and the remaining lingering problems—unless you are a big spender, that is. On a free account, which I started on, your memory tokens hovers around 4000 for one of the better AIs/Story Models, and while it works for a while—having any kind of longer adventure starts “the storyteller dementia.” Things will be dropped, a fact that is acceptable, but unfortunately it obliterates the immersion nonetheless every time. However, there are ways around this, provided by the devs… and money, of course.

Card of remembrance
One genius addition by the devs, instead of just solving it by force, is the so-called Story Cards and Plot-related info. On the Plot tab are the important things: the main quest, relationships, and the agendas of characters, but when it becomes really interesting is when we talk about Story Cards. These are cards of narration, something the AI collects when “reading” a trigger word, like the name of a character. This means you, or the scenario creator, can use this form of passive memory to force the Story Model to remember things. It’s a very cool system, and you can add essentially anything you like: events, loot, wounds, or even whole new characters you want to interact with, and as long as the trigger words are recognized, it works.

However, the downside to this is that it requires a lot of micromanagement. Especially if you are on a free account, since you will burn through the 4000 memory tokens fast. Paying for a subscription, which I did eventually, gives you a lot more leeway. You can’t eliminate the problem, but you can soften it, and you get access to the better Story Models too, even at the first tier. Frankly, it just gives you more memory tokens, the brute force way, but in combination with Story Cards, your adventure can go thousands of turns without too many issues, like a gaming nerd’s personal Lord of the Rings.

Fantasy fun
My three playthroughs (yes, three) of Slytherin to your Heart have been absolutely amazing. I have tasted victory against trolls and other foul things, I have felt true love and loyalty from the prettiest girl at school, the respect of my peers, and even a few adult experiences in a locked, abandoned dormitory room. It was all dynamic, which blows every conventional PC or console RPG out of the water, like a mini-nuke sent it flying. All this fun can and probably will take a toll, though, if you are like me—an eternal loner who dreams about romance on a daily basis. Heard about post-media depression? AI Dungeon is basically designed to overwhelm you with melancholy as soon as you hit the exit button. Being transported back to your own gray, cold, and unforgiving world hits you hard and fast.

This, of course, doesn’t have to be a problem if you are not like me, but even so, I would say the positives outweigh the negatives by far. It’s good and immersive entertainment after all, and your brain picks up many of the interactions as real, which had the effect of giving me a pep in the step when outside. The whole experience takes me back to school when you day-dreamed of your next gaming session, instead of solving that algebra conundrum in front of you—giving me strong flashbacks to a time when gaming was truly magical.

Conclusion
While AI Dungeon (2026) is not perfect, it’s a very immersive experience that I recommend to anyone who likes RPGs. Conventional games still have the upper hand, as in having proper gameplay, and are localized to your computer instead of a server—and when this changes, it will be revolutionary. But, I feel that is far off still, so I recommend giving AI Dungeon a go today!

Thanks for reading.

– Thomas

Leave a Reply